No products in the cart.
Our beloved Banana Pudding cookie is a fan favorite!
Handcrafted with fresh bananas, Nilla Wafers, and homemade pudding, and homemade whip for a true culinary experience!
* For shipping purposes, cookie topping is shipped separately in a small container for self-application.
Experience Campfire Bliss, a s'mores-inspired cookie featuring honey graham crackers, premium milk chocolate, and a toasted marshmallow center. Each bite brings back the nostalgic warmth of cozy nights under the stars. Enjoy the perfect blend of crunchy, gooey, and chocolaty goodness, and savor the sweet moments with this irresistible cookie!
A Milk Mustache favorite!
Our signature Chocolate Chip Cookie is a must-see and must-eat experience. With a golden, crisp exterior and a chocolate-studded center, it strikes the perfect balance of texture and flavor. Handcrafted with care, each cookie offers just the right amount of melty chocolate chips.
Whether it’s your go-to favorite or a new discovery, this best-seller always delivers pure cookie joy!
Cookies & Cream, a cookie like no other! Packed with real Oreo crumbles woven throughout and bursts of milk chocolate chips and white chocolate chunks, this treat is a delicious contrast of crunchy and smooth in every bite.
It’s a nostalgic twist on a classic, crafted for cookie lovers who crave something more. One bite and you’ll know—it’s more than just a cookie, it’s an experience!
Our Golden Goose features an irresistible combination of Golden Oreos and creamy white chocolate, hand rolled in colorful rainbow nonpareils. Each bite offers a burst of sweet, crunchy magic that's baked to perfection.
This best seller is your golden ticket to yummy bliss that's perfect for any occasion!
Our Red Velvet Cream Cheese is handcrafted with premium milk chocolate and filled with our homemade cream cheese frosting.
Delicious and decadent!
Discover our best-selling Snickerdoodle, a classic cinnamon sugar delight often hailed as the best snickerdoodle ever eaten. With its perfect balance of crispy edges and a soft, chewy center, each bite is a nostalgic trip to cookie heaven. Made with the finest ingredients and a touch of love, this timeless favorite is sure to please.
Treat yourself to the ultimate snickerdoodle experience today!
A best-seller for a reason, Nutella Dream features our signature vanilla dough, hand-crafted with a silky Nutella center and rolled in festive sanding sugar for a touch of sparkle. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of buttery richness and smooth hazelnut chocolate—making it an instant favorite.
Crunchy. Gooey. Delicious.
Indulge in our Sea Salt Caramel Pecan Cookie! This handcrafted Southern delight features rich caramel mixed with crunchy pecans, all perfectly topped with delicate sea salt flakes and baked with a crunchy exterior and gooey interior.
Savor the taste of Southern charm with every bite from Milk Mustache!
(Available online only, not in-store)
Often referred to as “the best oatmeal cookie”, our Oatmeal Chocolate Walnut is delicious at room temperature, and unbelievable when enjoyed warmed. Handcrafted with old fashioned oats, premium chocolate, and walnut halves.
Dive into our Black Forest Cheesecake Cookie—decadent chocolate, Oreo-coated, with a sweet cherry compote filling, layered in cheesecake glaze, and finished with a cherry spread.
**When shipping, cheesecake glaze and cherry spread are packaged separately for self-application.**
PB&J - Is a charming twist on the classic peanut butter & jelly sandwich! Handcrafted with creamy peanut butter and luscious grape jelly, this cookie brings back the nostalgic flavors of childhood, making it irresistibly delicious.
Indulge in the timeless joy of Milk Mustache's PB&J cookie today!
Get ready to perk up your palate with our Vanilla Cappuccino Cookie!
This artisan treat blends smooth vanilla with a bold espresso kick, topped with our house-made espresso whip for a light and fluffy finish. It's the perfect blend of cozy coffee shop vibes in every bite.
Whether you're looking for a morning boost or an afternoon treat, this cookie is sure to energize and enchant.
Savor the buzz—it’s coffee and cookie, rolled into one!
You have selected 0 items
1: Select flavors
2: Choose quantity per flavor
3: Add to cart
For multiple boxes, repeat the steps and assign boxes at checkout for multi-ship.
Single Address Shipments: We combine orders to minimize boxes shipped.
Find heating, freezing, allergen, and delivery info in our FAQ’s. Click here
Quantity
Username or email *
Password *
Remember me
Login Resset Password
Email address *
A password will be sent to your email address.
Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.
Register
